April 25th, 2008

after all

One star reviews

Over on his blog, John Scalzi amuses his readers once again with some prized quotes from select Amazon reviews. He then invites other writers to do the same.

I'm not a writer, but it did make me curious to see what Amazon's reviewers had to say about Girl Genius, and if there would be choice bits to highlight.

Well, Volume One has eleven reviews - all 5 star.
Volume Two has nine reviews, 8 for 5 stars, 1 for 4 stars.
Volume Three has two reviews, both 5 star. (and is the only book offered without a discount)
Volume Four seven reviews, 5 for 5 stars, 2 for 4 stars.
Volume Five has five reviews, all 5 star.
and Volume Six has five reviews, 4 for 5 stars, 1 for 4 stars.

So, no pithy one-star complaints to pass on, but a fun afternoon of reading.